A British study into smoking and e-cigarette use among UK teenagers has produced mixed results, prompting scientists to caution against altering policy decisions or public health advice until evidence becomes clearer.
The research, published online in the British Medical Journal's specialized Tobacco Control journal on Aug 17, suggests there may be evidence e-cigarettes could be leading UK
teenagers to try tobacco smoking. But the results do not fit with underlying smoking trends and drew criticism from external experts.
The findings show that among teenagers who at the start of the survey say they had never smoked cigarettes but had tried e-cigarettes, more than a third, or 34.4 percent, say a year
later that they had tried cigarettes. This compared with only 9 percent in the group who had not tried e-cigarettes when the survey began.
Yet the study's researchers, led by Mark Conner of the University of Leeds, urge caution in interpreting its results, noting that while e-cigarette use has increased in Britain, rates of
smoking have continued to fall.
"While acknowledging that a causal relationship may be plausible, we cannot confirm this based on our findings and the trends observed over the same period in the UK," they write.
"Given the lack of clarity regarding the mechanism linking e-cigarette and cigarette use, we need to be cautious in making policy recommendations based on our findings."
The global scientific community is divided over e-cigarettes and whether or not they are a useful public health tool as a nicotine-replacement therapy.
Many specialists, including health experts at Public Health England, think e-cigarettes, which contain nicotine but no tobacco, are a lower-risk alternative to smoking.
But the US surgeon general last year urged lawmakers to impose price and tax policies that would discourage their use.
Robert West, a professor of health psychology at University College London, says Conner's team was right to warn that this latest study did not show a causal connection between
e-cigarette use and starting smoking.
"It seems unlikely that e-cigarette use by young people is causing more of them to smoke, because smoking rates in this age group now are declining at least as fast as they
were before e-cigarettes started to become popular," West says.
Linda Bauld, a professor of health policy at the University of Stirling, says the study did not provide evidence that using e-cigarettes causes young people to become smokers.
"It simply shows that some teenagers who try an e-cigarette might go on to try tobacco, and on both occasions it could be just once," she says.
"If e-cigarettes were causing smoking, then the steady decline in youth smoking we've seen in national surveys in recent years would be reversed. But it's not－smoking among
young people in the UK is at an all-time low."